Lease structuring or lease staggering as a vacancy risk management strategy: How Smart Lease Structuring Can Maximize Your Rental Returns

Lease structuring or lease staggering as a vacancy risk management strategy: How Smart Lease Structuring Can Maximize Your Rental Returns

One of the most under-utilized strategies for managing vacancy risk and ensuring consistent cash flow is intentional lease structuring — specifically, staggering lease expiry dates.

Instead of allowing a bulk of your leases to end at the same time (e.g., year-end or mid-year), experienced, multi-tenant landlords and property managers spread out lease terms across the calendar year. This approach reduces the risk of mass vacancies and avoids the pressure of handling dozens of renewals, negotiations, or move-outs all at once.

With the exception of periods like the Covid-19, this is a tried and proven strategy to ensure consistent cash flows in your buildings or portfolio and here is an example from a prominent commercial building we studied (though no names will be used for anonymity):

At the time, the landlord had 43 tenants and structured his leases (unconsciously) in a way that:

• 16 leases ended in December (end of year),
• Another group of 12 or slightly more expired around June (end of financial year),
• The rest were spread across the remaining months.

On paper, this looked manageable and ideal because it allowed for easy filing and follow up of leases. But in reality, this setup created large gaps and put nearly half the portfolio at risk of turnover at predictable intervals.

Again, Covid was a good example of this, trust me when I say a lot of landlords were saved because the law was unclear on what was to happen and most could comfortably enforce their leases, but if tables had turned, it would have been disastrous because people were acting irrationally, it wasn’t business as usual.

Worse still, tenants nearing lease expiry often show a not so pleasant behavioral pattern:

• Delaying rent payments, especially in the final month,
• Skipping the last payment, assuming it’ll be taken from their security deposit,
• Being unresponsive, knowing they don’t intend to renew.

These challenges can significantly impact your short-term revenue and make your cash flow unpredictable, that’s why this strategy is important to consider.

Why Staggering Leases Matters:

• ✅ Consistent Income – Even if some tenants leave, others are mid-term, keeping revenue steady.
• ✅ Better Operational Control – Avoid the chaos of simultaneous inspections, listings, and negotiations.
• ✅ Improved Risk Management – You’re never overly exposed to market shifts in a single season.
• ✅ More Strategic Renewals – With fewer leases expiring at once, you can give each renewal more attention, increasing retention.

Pro Tip for Landlords and Property Managers:

Start thinking in cycles and tenant segments. Mix your lease terms:

• 6-month, 12-month, 18-month agreements (depending on tenant type).
• Align some leases with off-peak periods for better market positioning.
• Negotiate mid-term extensions to rebalance clusters.

With the market, it’s not just about avoiding vacancy — it’s about controlling it.

I hope you liked this segment of threalty insights, please be sure to subscribe and follow us so you never miss any of these insights, ciao